Tiểu luận SỰ TƯƠNG ĐỒNG VÀ KHÁC BIỆT GIỮA TRIẾT HỌC DUY VẬT VÀ TRIẾT HỌC DUY TÂM Ở HY LẠP THỜI CỔ ĐẠI
Bạn đang xem bản rút gọn của tài liệu. Xem và tải ngay bản đầy đủ của tài liệu tại đây (216.36 KB, 19 trang )
!"#"$%
&'()*+,-."/$(
."/01/#2
3#4567 *8 5
399:
!"#$%3*;<=
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
#1>"
&0123454678345(9%:3;<=!>=!
?'>=/3@A3?B345%&'(*'C81$8>;
?1(3DE!345(9%1!=%
F>345%&'(*'BDGCAHI3!@%A=1J6
>=!AA=K8L(!=3?1K!AA=K8L(BBDD4!
!AA=M=D=NBC8345O=%L345O=%9A345
O=%LO=%9A)*%&'(:B BB(<=!35P
?>345(9%AQ?>345E!98?'P<=!1
E!RS>=%1TGUAD=V<=!D=
8=L6>&'(")*"+%,"-$./012$./01
341567)58G3U%1!=9%-D=8=L:!A;?AH
1K8=,?@3)S'5W4( #/!EM
!(XA@F=%Y =#="#$
FZ-C30[=K!FHXB@F=%YF5=%&'(#
$FZ-*G((\XC@]^1^,)*+,)=%
MO?)!_3UHQ'4MD=8=LPD3
` 4=1B#U4^AA?LG1BB(a41b;?
LUE!@%
cAd9;Ae
#,&M0F5-C 3!
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
D5EFGHFIJK6 5LM NOEPO5 Q#RO5G SF
9:!;<=>
90+
%&'(*'8AH<=K!3H86BCL=PQ!-!?AA>F!A
;?-!/f-!8!1gA>^D(C!9%D=h>=Q;?$
A>c^^3?B<=!35N8A>F!A;?-!/I8.
8i0!%&'(>8i0!%&'(>A70!UG!!=
-J3=F!AHAB>=j3.(R3N=L8G?335
#.)D(C!PE!;?-!/R=k='?M>=0
>=;;3N=L8G?(3D;;?3M)Dc^^
3$3'Ab9?=%>8'l%&'(4D=h-J
3?B86N8;?3m$(C!F!A;?3?BDc^^8'
AH86MA;1BABnM'?>==L8G?>
D3?>=>4'?==%>QP1QD=h8AH
.=B84@=K8>%&'(66(SP*'B
>/A(3D16A
#6>=M=L8GL%M%&'(*'16A3$AH
<=K!4A =P8BAH>P((3DAH>/
B!@(?(R!O'FB>=34!A348aE!5:3$M
NE
9?+.
%&'(*'jA$AH03CP.=L8G>CL=N!D;
8QE!?)8 L8PD?O=%!%
*A$3HAK!!?(3D4
#,&M0F5-C 3!
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
4k#ooop#o3F9%8)q<=!35N3?8012%&'(*
'8)q98?'=%Dl)'1!)'1J&RN%)
1JGO.(*4/1=N8!?H/!1;(rAOO?4H
1$ =9GEK(3D%:m?^?(9P8!?H
3?P( !335/=PZ=6=%D
1!4H4A =P8:D%3sm(3DA'AT
E!P(EP(l=K4k#ooo3F88r%<=!35
?3!?*=P!?8=6.89L
9?@$<ABCD
(3D>4:Ot41U>C30pd:H1(9
B!!N(3?d:H41I3s3Z:H!!!N(d=H!=
8EPP8FP8B1K8GP;?3?d:H1KL(3=#5
_C888G1;d=NE%4=3?d:Hf3?1;d=NP(
EP((AL=O0;g+!N(EP_(9
B!EP<=aHEPO9E&!?H0(9B!8!?H
9!%8!?H3CB9==t !EPP8%!%J:
8A?AIH8E!=HN=3! !EP6P8%/
SN60(9!>=6`u68N%AH(K8A
3=9A3?B(!3^v^8!(K*.A'NK
?8012%&'(*'!v^jA$.j=H3=
H%&'(B>=0!8a=L8GM:3$AH3=9A4/
B!E!%8'(*'8PE!3459=w=I61(
3D4/B!8446EPO9Ev^-M'B
(!3^jA$.U=%MN!3NCG(61(3DP
(EP<=aH^?8K!3=%>?KCU4(!3^:
d9%OAH446<=9E1(I3NK6P
#,&M0F5-C 3!\
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
8=%MO.G*I^?UI?UD=6%>=8
Pi=%MCE!!N(EP
3!<=%>E%&'(:Ot4=H43!m?O
i/A !!!3M64<=;=K.81N'E!
v^m?^?B811=%%4=MA35>4C30<=91E!
N6%&'(43!x?B:8A;%1=H*OL%E!@86(
P8=%MO?d=N(l>=H8'!=PBP =
PB<=%>'PG!A!??'Hd:HC30M
=H*OL%:4R3?N'6(8N%)=!8($(C!-J%
&'(:^A<=9d9A4A?H;?%&'(?4koo3F%&'(0
3?!%E!4<=K&!:=%4<=K&!:(iG%&'(
8'0%&'((i>/B!
#U>=4=@==P3!?*B!A=%4G
D46(SP3$M)d=%MCU4@AU
E!5_GA$3HF =/B!E!vL(-!8?:8A
?)%&'('MN;8y %4=KE!6'>=
G)%&'(BL
3?)'%%&'(:d9%OGAH>/AP.d8'
6 =33z=H8y!=R81$U
M>/A(9%'
#>/5)%&'(:D8'AH?/5@?'3N(?
(R L(I!!U;A $0N(Ot(;=H1K
1PH8!?H>b=HN=3!M)K8' 88G
Md:HE!)%&'(*'
#>=L:D8' P3U43RM=JH5!30
#,&M0F5-C 3!
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
#>8=L((:16Ad9%OAH>((8=LGMA
'!v^
#>?!5M =?5M/L8a{G
?!5M=*!8^1%!?^3!8^16A(3!#7
)%8'(*':D8'AHO1;345P.1H19=1J
9$)6%$EF$.157)5
&012345%&'(*'J8>680123!)E!>C30%
&'(*'(;8012E!N6%"?L%BD!801234
5%&'(*'3!\)q,
96+GHIJ.+K?L$9MN
S9%8)q4H4A =P8A6U"?1(3DE!1;
d=N46<=!_BCNP?@?'O@O@)u?
D=4?!5>?)>_3i3M1$B3456
8AH?!5!?<=A53I8|)An}E!?!5
3?)q%Ey!O=%L!?A,3)(8M?3jB
DLN@=MyYLH'?3!A5L3M46f6
!8mB86v!dA/38!(^3?Qv!dA^8PCgX3)
(M3!8C?3j;=%ME!_3i882!3?BEy!O=%
9A)%B345=H3)(~8MZMP(!AMC
"MP3)(%!?8'B <=!DAO=%9A1M=U>=
K_3i
96+GHJ,O)P0Q.+K?$9MN
S9%8)q4H4A =P8(3D4UI!?_8
)q(E!345%&'(*')q%KGMI=
E!345GA$3H1!N>>4N=E!LNLI8=L
#,&M0F5-C 3!•
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
)1KC303?B4N=LN8N>3=9AE!>=
3)(345
Ey!O=%L)%B3)(!=%McA(MKpv!d!?=%
M'4b!?E!Ey!O=%L)%83)(=%M28=L
&dC(pSMAP3C?3jA5L>=GN=l=%M2SK8L(8'
B83)(O=%9A<=!E!8!P?3j6MJ=
laA€ !!3)(O=%LO=%9A3M83450=%M
E!v3dK
96+GH,JQ.+KLLL$9MN
S9%8)qE?;1=%?E!4H4A =P8$%&'(
.611=%B>/B!AB1;13!_1=%^?
345%&'(*':73!@=4N>E!345A!)
N%AK<=!E!R63?8==%63451!=%
5TUTO 57VIOEPO5 WQVXOVWQOYZO5GQ#R SF
9$./0126157)5
345O=%LGUl3)(8M•3)(M3!8C
3)(!=%McA(MK•v!d!?'Gb!?3?3)
(=%M28=L&dC(pSMAP3C
9$'6"%R;
S9%83)(O=%LIN(@=M3?345%
&'(*'3?)%8M8AH3=9AA';86C
>=%:'?>=A$3H@AUE!?)CC1(3D
E!?!5/B!F 345M=D==H3)(8M8
!8mv!dA/3v!dA^P?@?'3=%>Kf?
@88=%M9'?3!46g?3j;=%ME!468AH
#,&M0F5-C 3!‚
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
LDd0SBB(<=!35NE!3)(8M8:7>AB
?1UA345D34!1!=%4(i*1=
8A(?(RMA ABALNP!1
N=3! !A7K8L({H>=<=!35 !834!:UA
;C46AHG(8al;946MIP(;
8lM?B
9$'6"%$;@
M3!8C8AH34516AD3s$IN(l
)*%&'(ƒ?;=%ME!46882!51L8=P$3'
LH4*(3DPl46AHOQ;%I3P
A:lBP!3!8=LDA*4|-./012'34
15}LH(3D8MiE!A51L^?
M3!8C8O?CN%4=<=!8??1f<=%8=L3Lg<=%0SBB(
;E!M3!8C??801234598?'83U%@=M
><=%8=LKN !A7K8L(
9$'6"%)"01S)TAUB":
cA(MKpv!d!?d9%O<=!A!=%M>;NE!46L
N!O'cA(MKl!L$=%ME!468K%4=K,N6
PC82!v!!d??3j'L13!l| 'K}F '
K%`(9!4PLv!!d?d^A|AuI!A5}
=%M<=!DAE!5_QA!C1!y!8Q'4
F '4%G=%4(i$=%4=%M28=L
9V$'6"%"01>;02
&dC(8)18L(MSMAP3C8)4l!(3>!
3)(=%M28=L8Mb!?E!345O=%L%&'(*'
3?!?'0&dC(8)@=MM=8MA>=%M
#,&M0F5-C 3!„
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
2SMAP3C:4l!(3D=%4=%M23MAH(OA6
^?P=%M29PC8/=%ME!1LG
9$./0136157)5
345O=%9AGU3?3)(%!?3;<=!3)(
~8M'Gb!?3?3)(O=%9A<=!E!8!?
9$'6"%W1":
W6<=!AE!>=3)(345%&'(*'?$
=%ME!468AHO'LNiD?B%!???1K8$
=%ME!468;NE!1L8<=%8=LE!_3iFO?<=>
!?!3QE!?1K4R 88G1M=M%!?
$=%48=9?3j80!A:A3?Dd+;?8
3!`13=HE!4d8AiCE!=H1K
9$'6"%X;
3)(~8MO?ZMP(!8L(^?@O=%L1!=B
GAMC(3D^?6O=%9AG"MP;?(=%
0=;$)!8mZMP(!?3jA5>=lNA3!=K
.3$>6N.66N'?M11KE!A=P8?AMC8'
?3j|'}8;N=DCKNE!'L3?4
6|'}8AH('A3.345A!C<=!?GLI
$O=%8aC"MP8);?3)(~8Mƒ!3!
!(P3DIA3jPDO.3<=!;ACDLI1
LA(;O.O=%3l==%M1!8@AE!P8$u=%K
B!C?'3!`C8MiE!LH
#,&M0F5-C 3!…
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
9$'6"%/013+%Y0FZ[$%AW;[
3)(%D8L(3)C30E!@86(EP<=aH;?E
K8'>O9Ev^K345O=%LE!3)(=%M2
8=LSGd9%O$ZP3G?$8!P
W6 345ZP3PMI=>6MA
PO(@86MI=>?)'?I8!Pd=N93?AH!
UEP<=aH$v^ƒ:d9%OEy!O=%9A<=!6
HO=C8=%4aA630M3?8(m(IE!
A>=$19=1J>'?IC30d:H{
9$.<"01FU$BT
v3dK853Qd=N1JNE!8!P=%MP8'(M(=%4a
AE!@%U^?PaA8'M?H8L(61LM
BPD8;NE!1LFP_PEH<=!DAE!
3)(O=%L>$=%MLNE!_3ilBP!
3!=%4=%M9p1$E!M=U5=%4LHp1$E!#L
8a5=%345E!PO!?H !Ey!O=%LO=%9A
P:A$3!AH93)A6?1(3DE!?!5(9%
[O=\7F]7VJ5T 57^OEPO5 WQVXOVOEPO5 WQOYZ
O5GQ#R SF
9'(")*""-$./012$./0136157)5
345%&'(*'8345E!!N(EPK303?d:H%
&'()N%)?M345%&'()*'!%lA63!):
A!C;C!N(19=1JS>=%D$=HN=3! !E
y!O=%LO=%9A !!(((I1M=U{".8
^?Ey!O=%L!%O=%9AO.8I!%1M=U{N;
#,&M0F5-C 3!†
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
345%&'(*'>==H!N(EP>=;??!N(
E!5
345%&'(*'!%lA63!):>L(4>=N>
!=,F=KE!468U‡=H)1K(LE!?)4
?‡<=!A>C30pd:H{F N>%8=PG;<=%4
3?Ey!O=%L?7O=%9A
345%&'(*':d=N(m(IN(34
58RN%)<=!1GMAH34(S)1
4(dR6>=1?' 3IE!98?'E!6
:B((@8AU(3D(m(I1!E!345
%&'(*'=%3j5!3U%RAHK8a8=L7T
345%&'(*'JB7T6?!5)N%)34
5)8?!55<=!1GMD3R3!4
8=L345E!5#UL%:d=N<=!DA?3j|3458?!5
E!?!5}
3?Ey!O=%LO=%9AE!345%&'(*'>=I!
>=A@AABE!46<=!'1!=%S>=%BG8O?34
5%&'(*'G;%1l>=.!==H%&'(*B:
(3DAH!O'(?(R
345%&'(*'>L(4>=N>?)1K(L?)
7O.345QB a4!=>;N?)>
AK<=! !8Dd5>=?35?)??
)8?!!?<=aE!'?B!)%&'(*'30?)E%4=
bG4$C!''?I!?4(LI8=L
9+%,"-$./012$./0136157)5
#,&M0F5-C 3!
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
!BDMI=1!=%P<=!!345M=D=
'O?!Ey!8SMAP3CfEy!O=%Lg8!PfEy!
O=%9Ag
SMAP3C13$3?AH!UEPO9E$%&'(ƒ!AD=
?5L8a15AV5{Gˆ^Gd^A8HB
?!@=ME!)%&'(*'8!Pd=N93?AH!U
EP<=aH$v^8AH3? 345$d=NN
)*')A^?M^B;$?86443U(3D
$6/B!@E!98?'
678279 :;,SMAP3C?3jH=E!4
68=%M28LNƒ:(3D=%4=%M2E!&dC(p)
@%E!Pp8M3UHA6F=%M28'LN`P(9!
GPUN%GPA=PA.P0P9A!
'yY=%M2N>Nb!=>8GU
IfN='?g>4fd?!%3$g>3Lf44(gU!3:1
!=E!1LG8O?14G(!%3!E!=%M2
^? I!=(i=H?1!=E!=%M2
3?B^?8!P_3i%B!46846<146=
>)ƒ‰03j;=%ME!46C846<1AH4
63l=G9=%KN4yjO=%N&8O?
@'?3!Q46 => ;ACb81;(rAE!|46a
A}b8|B}E!RMB8|'P9}#UA5
3?B8=P4*B13!BANBb8BE!46aA
O?46aA<=%40ŠAE!8!P8=PAt=D46
1L;ACAP(`^?
67?@,[=!A>_3iE!SMAP3CPBu?@3?
BbB =%M2LH^? 8Kd?%=%M2.
#,&M0F5-C 3!
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
8?'K46!=8A Q86(=%M27$@
9An$d!9ASN682!PC8 Q$3=9A
8KlBU3NQ68!P_3i%P
'b8G@8'?3!jAP(`^?46<1
67=A'B,^?SMAP3C11K?)P(;O?
@'?3!A84<=;N%4=E!M(3DlN(4!?
LB8Q1LUPB8&G'?l
=%M2U@=nB=%DH!B;2&AN
.64E!?)S>=%3G??68!P8!P
?3jDd?)GN=lN682!PCQ8
O?@!?MN2FP8^?PP(;8?)b
8Pi4BPB8
67>,SMAP3C!LILIA)KLI1
1=KFLIA)K8LIO?<=!A!8'FLI11=K
!%LI8aC8LIO?1(9C19=1J1LDJAG
;NE!BFLI;AC8>>E!LI8aCQ8!P8'
=%KB!!3QE!LI8aCƒ?3jLI;ACb8
|$G} |4;}>|BE!aA}MBP
9bB8aC$3UH|33C=}A6N%G|aA}B
A689|33C=}C8<=3U$E!8&
68' UB:N%3s'$|46aA}AB:<=M
!L(?Dd?)
672&2,SMAP3C6'?I?)1K^?P1D=
481$E!'?IKB'?I81KRAPQ!P
9%'?AU?)Q8!P6'?I?)1KE!46
aAƒ?3jbB@86(345<=aHA6''?I
#,&M0F5-C 3!
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
!!?Q'?IE!)O9b81UA4Oi5N(xFP8
PB'?I
67C#DEF,SMAP3C8345;?4H4A =P8
=%MPI3M8L(3)E!EPO9EB4H‰'P
Q`(;B8=L/D<=;8ad:HƒM=5EP(;Kd2
6P8H(L3MD?)^?P<=;8a6
(;?AH=LA!8'??)'(R<=!O?
O9E3?B8!P8'I3M8L(3)E!EP<=aHD;?
4H4A =P8jA5ƒ:>3!((8d9%OAH
6A!CP$6A$BB>=CNA!C
<=9(‰',PQdB!`1$ =!UX3‹^A13!(;
!?3)PDlB8!53!345P
?)(i=H?6(;(ii63?
6P$%^?PB!86(),345P
8AAi<=;8a>=d:HX48AP;?d:HX
F )8!?H9!%D;A;?)1KLN?d:HFP8
PG?8)MP=H86()?
BDN%3j!%l)*'LIE!?)=%Q>='
41? !EFy!"=%#LEFy!"=%9A:UM=H
N=3!!%JPD>=?G>A5A73?d:H
#,&M0F5-C 3!\
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
#"$
345%&'(*'Pb8P8>;E!3M345
(9%AQBB(?8012345E!;98?'7O.B1
N=3!!%J !345O=%L345O=%9AU=34
5%&'(*'B!3QPD(EL3?<=3UUAD=;C
1LGd=<=!=H1K?)8a;!%;;
9?)XB(P?1(3DE!?!5)1K#6 B
B(?86L%ˆ^:Ldm1!=,|lUIA=PU
A=P‹E!345&'(:BA@AAK!;%$@=4N;
8?'46<=!1!=%}FLdm%(@?D?!N%@A<=!
35E!345%8'(*'_ UAB:^A4?R
!Pb83? $>345AQ;3??!5)
1K
#,&M0F5-C 3!
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
(#+"-_`
g3)S'5W4( #/!EM
!(
gF=%Y =#="#$FZ-C30[=K!FH
\gF=%YF5= %&'(#$FZ-*G((
\
g]^1^,)*+,))
#,&M0F5-C 3!•
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
a#a
!" "#$%"&'()*+",-./0!"1 /"
G)HI#$))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))J
G)G%7=)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))J
2#%",
32#4(5678"3
J)K=2B+/:H "&+L2&)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))M
!"%9:;<,%=2>?@
!"%9:"<AB C$D,%=2>?@
3!"%9:A<D,%=>?E
F"G$$H#",-I$.HJHI$.KL!"./01 /"E
G) >BH "&+L2&))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))N
M!0""'NOE
M!0"N'4OP
3M!0" $.NQL0N R5S6P
M!0"$.N*'$JP
J) O1BH "&+L2&)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))P
M!0".T
M!0"U'NT
3M!0"I$.KL%G$+VW5'WX
Q)# :REA))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))S
YZM[ \H%$"]",-I$.HJH",-I$.KL!"./01 /"X
G)K='(2TU > O1BH "&+L2&))))))))))))))))))))S
F^_>
`aSFbc@
ddE
HVTH: Lê Th Ngc -C i&i
!"#"$%&'()*'+#", #/!
HVTH: Lê Th Ngc -C i&i
