July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0
IEEE P802.11
Wireless LANs
Minutes of the IEEE P802.11 Full Working Group
Date: 2012-07-16

Author(s):
Name
Stephen
McCann

Company
Research in Motion
(RIM) UK Ltd

Address
200 Bath Road, Slough,
Berkshire, SL1 3XE, UK

Phone

email

+44 1753 667099



Abstract
This document constitutes the minutes of the IEEE 802.11 full working group for the July 2012,

San Diego, CA, USA meeting.
Please note that all affiliations at this meeting are shown in Annex A.

Minutes

page 1

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

IEEE 802.11 Plenary Meeting – Session #134
Manchester Grand Hyatt, San Diego, CA, USA
July 16th – 20th, 2012
IEEE 802.11 Opening Plenary, Monday 16th July 2012
Presiding chair: Bruce Kraemer (Marvell Semiconductor) opened the meeting at 11:26 PDT.
Jon Rosdahl
Adrian Stephens
Stephen McCann

Vice-chair 1 (VC1)
Vice-chair 2 (VC2)
Secretary

CSR
Intel
Research in Motion


There are 294 voting members of IEEE 802.11

1. Approve/modify joint opening agenda (11-12-0720r2)
1.1. Chair: This is the main agenda for the week and shows the allocation of meetings to time slots.
1.2. Chair: Any modifications to the agenda? None seen.
1.3. No objection to the approval of the agenda.

2. Notices
2.1. Please note that photographs and recording devices are not allowed in these meetings and put
cell phones to vibrate please.
2.2. Chair: We will be asking for pictures to be taken on Wednesday for awards, but otherwise this is
not allowed.

3. Attendance
3.1. Please can you remember to login and register your attendance.
3.2. 10 people attended this meeting for the first time out of 220 people in the room.
3.3. Chair: Please note that there is a newcomer training session will be after lunch at 13:30 in room
“Windsor 3”

4. May 2012 (Atlanta) WG Minutes (11-12-0636r1)
4.1. Move to approve the May 2012 minutes
4.2. Moved: Stephen McCann, 2nd: Richard Kennedy
4.3. Following neither discussion nor dissent the minutes were approved by unanimous consent.

5. Financials (11-12-0865r2)
5.1. VC1: This is the treasury report for 2012 and specifically the Atlanta 2012 meeting.
5.2. There was a very small deficit of around $100 for this meeting.
Minutes


page 2

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

5.3. The first column is the budgeted figure and the 2nd is the actual figure.
5.4. Question (Q): So was the Atlanta meeting a loss or gain.
5.5. Answer (A): It was a loss, but this was the first loss since 2008.

6. Policy and Procedures (11-12-0847r0)
6.1. VC1: Regarding patent information, please view for IEEE-SA patent information and also 11-12-0045r1.
6.2. The VC1 called for essential patents information.
6.3. No statements were made.
6.4. VC1: I would also like to mention other guidelines for this meeting.
6.5. Chair: Also, there is also a link to the LoA database in 11-12-0183r0
6.6. ( />6.7. There are also some updates to the 802 LMSC P&Ps which will be hopefully approved this
week (slide #9). There also some minor changes to the IEEE 802.11 Operations Manual (OM)
6.8. No questions

7. Announcements (11-12-0721r0)
7.1. Missing chairs and replacements
7.1.1. Please note that all the main offices are here this week, so no replacements are required.
7.1.2. No questions
7.2. Joint Meetings this week
7.2.1. Chair: Thursday AM1 with IEEE 802.1 to discuss bridging.
7.2.2. Thursday AM2 with IEEE 802.1, with an IEEE 1905.1 report. IEEE 1905.1 intend to

produce an abstraction layer including IEEE 802.11 and other IEEE 802 technologies.
7.2.3. No questions
7.3. PAR Meetings this week
7.3.1. Chair: There are some PAR meetings this week, to review the PARs of the other IEEE 802
Working Groups (WG).
7.3.2. There are 5 Pars this week:
• 802.16q, amendment for multi-tier networks, PAR and 5C
• 802.16.3, new standards for mobile broadband network performance measurements, PAR and
5C
• 802.3bm, amendment for 40 Gb/s and 100 Gb/s Operation Over Fiber Optic Cables, PAR and
5C
• 802.3bn, amendment for Ethernet Passive Optical Networks Protocol over Coax Networks,
PAR and 5C
• 802.11aj, amendment for Enhancements for Very High Throughput to support one or more of
the Chinese 40-50 GHz and 59-64 GHz frequency bands, PAR and 5C
7.3.3. If you are interested in any of them, please come along to one of the PAR sessions, chaired
by Jon Rosdahl. Otherwise, please send him an email. These will then be reviewed during
the IEEE 802.11 closing plenary.
7.3.4. Chair: We also have a new revision PAR for TGmc and extension PAR for TGac

Minutes

page 3

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0


7.4. Meeting Rooms and other IEEE 802 meetings (11-12-0722r0)
7.4.1. Chair: Please note we are meeting over several levels this week.
7.4.2. Most of the other groups have agendas as shown in slide #10
7.4.3. Breakfast is served outside of this meeting room and the social will be around the outside
pool on Floor 4. Please can you obtain a badge from the registration desk for any guests.
7.5. September 2012 in Indian Wells, California, USA
7.5.1. Chair: Please note that the hotel booking and registration are now both open. Please note
the early bird cut-off dates.
7.6. IEEE 802 / IETF joint meeting
7.6.1. Chair: There is a joint meeting next week in San Jose between these two organizations.
There will be some discussions this week. We currently have 6 people representing IEEE
802.11 at that meeting.
7.6.2. There will an IEEE 802 EC meeting tomorrow evening between 8 – 9pm on this topic.
7.7. IEEE-SA
7.7.1. Chair: There is now a new Managing Director for the IEEE-SA, as described in slide #16.
7.8. IEEE 802 ExCom
7.8.1. There is a lot of material for the IEEE 802 ExCom from IEEE 802.11 this week:
7.8.2. Requests to submit to RevCom: 11ad Conditional
7.8.3. New project PAR to NesCom: CMMW
7.8.4. PAR Extension: 11ac
7.8.5. Revision PAR: 11REVmc
7.8.6. Study Group start up: Depends upon results of WNG meeting
7.8.7. Study Group extension: ISD & CMMW
7.9. IEEE 802.1 Architecture (D1.4)
7.9.1. The last ballot passed at 79%.
7.10. SmartGrid
7.10.1. There will be 802 EC level meetings regarding SmartGrid this week.
7.11. Wednesday
7.11.1. There are other topics for discussion, which will come up on Wednesday as shown in

slide #21.
7.12. Tutorials
7.12.1. There are 3 tutorials scheduled for this week as shown in slide #22.
7.13. Student Outreach
7.13.1. There will 11 students coming along to IEEE 802.11 on Tuesday as part of the IEEE 802
outreach program.

8. Documentation and Attendance (11-12-0038r3)
Minutes

page 4

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

8.1. VC2: The ANA has nothing to report at the moment.
8.2. The meeting registration indicates that 258 people are present this week and there are currently
294 voters.
8.3. Please remember to do your attendance.
8.4. There is an online calendar if you wish to download it for your device.
8.5. No questions

9. Publicity (11-12-0880r0)
9.1. Secretary: Briefly explained the status of the merged 11aa and 11ae press release.
9.2. No questions


10.

Status of all groups (11-12-0721r0)

10.1. The status of each group was presented.
10.2. Chair: Please note that IEEE 802.11-2012 is the most downloaded document from the IEEE at
the moment.
10.3. Some extra notes not covered in the slides:
10.3.1. Editor’s Meeting: This occurs at 7am on Tuesday morning
10.3.2. WNG: There are 11 presentations scheduled for this week, which will be covered during
3 separate sessions.
10.4. No questions

11.

Any Other Business

11.1. Comment (C): Just a reminder of the newcomers session at 13:30 in room Windsor B
11.2. Q: Are there any lunch arrangements?
11.3. Chair: Not that I know of.
11.4. Chair: No objections to recess. Meeting recessed at 12:29 PDT

Minutes

page 5

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012


doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

Wednesday, 18th July 2012
IEEE 802.11 Mid Week Plenary
Presiding chair: Bruce Kraemer (Marvell Semiconductor) opened the meeting at 10:30 PDT
186 people present.

12.

Approve/modify joint opening agenda (11-12-0720r4)

12.1. Chair: There are some adjustments which have been made to this document.
12.2. C: Please can I move the Radio Regulatory summary to Friday please?
12.3. Chair: Yes
12.4. Any objection to accepting this change to the agenda, with the exception of that change to the
Radio Regulatory report.
12.5. No objection, so moved and approved.

13.

Call for Essential Patents

13.1. Call for essential patents
13.2. None

14.

CAC (Chair’s Advisory Committee)


14.1. Reminder about the CAC meeting at 19:30 on Thursday. Need to consider documentation for
the IEEE 802 Executive Committee (EC) meeting on Friday.

15.

Announcements

15.1. Social
15.2. This starts at 6.30pm in this hotel on level 4 around the hotel pool area. Please can you
remember to obtain badges for any guest, otherwise they will not be allowed in.

16.

Liaisons

16.1. IEEE 802.19 : Co-existence (11-12-0942r0)
16.1.1. No questions
16.2. Bluetooth SIG
16.2.1. There are no specific issues to report, but the relationship between Bluetooth SIG and
IEEE 802 continues especially in the area of SmartGrid.
16.3. Wi-Fi Alliance (WFA)
16.3.1. No report this time
Minutes

page 6

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012


doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

16.4. IETF (11-12-0932r0)
16.4.1. Chair: Please note that there is a joint IEEE 802 and IETF meeting next week in Milpitas,
California. There is an obligation within IEEE 802 to have some sort of order, so Jon
Rosdahl will represent IEEE 802.11 in my absence.
16.5. 3GPP
16.5.1. There is nothing to report this time.
16.5.2. No questions

17.

Proposed Changes to IEEE 802.11 Operations Manual (OM) (11-12-

0874r1)
17.1. VC1: Here are two proposed changes to the IEEE 802.11 OM.
17.2. Q: So what is a session exactly?
17.3. A: A session is the whole week, a meeting slot is a 2 hour block.
17.4. C: …and the attendance tool currently tracks by meeting slots.
17.5. C: So you can gain attendance credit and also send an email?
17.6. A: Yes
17.7. VC1: We’ll bring a formal motion for this update on Friday.
17.8. No questions

18.

Working Group Motions (Old Business) (11-12-0735r2)

18.1. TGad RevCom Conditional Approval (slide #4)

18.1.1. Approve document 11-12/0885r2 as the report to the IEEE 802 Executive
Committee on the requirements for conditional approval to forward P802.11ad D9.0 to
RevCom, and Request the IEEE 802 Executive Committee to conditionally approve
forwarding P802.11ad D9.0 to RevCom.
18.1.2. Moved by Eldad Perahia, Second: Donald Eastlake
18.1.3. [TGad vote for 11-12-0885r1: Moved: Solomon Trainin, Sai Nandagopalan, Result: 12-01]
18.1.4. Chair: This will be presented to the EC on Friday afternoon if it passes.
18.1.5. For: 117, Against: 0, Abstain: 0 (Motion passes 100%)
18.2. CMMW PAR (slide #10)
18.2.1. Believing that the PAR content contained in the document referenced below meets
IEEE-SA guidelines, Request that the PAR content contained in 802.11-12/0140r9 be
posted to the IEEE 802 Executive Committee (EC) agenda for WG 802 preview and EC
approval to submit to NesCom.
18.2.2. Moved by Xiaoming Peng on behalf of CMMW SG, Second: Stuart Kerry
18.2.3. For: 99, Against: 0, Abstain: 8 (Motion passes 100%)
18.3. CMMW 5 Criteria (slide #11)
18.3.1. Believing that the Five Criteria contained in the document referenced below meets
IEEE 802 guidelines, Request that the Five Criteria contained in 802.11-12/0141r7 be
posted to the IEEE 802 Executive Committee (EC) agenda for WG 802 preview and EC
approval.
Minutes

page 7

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0


18.3.2. Moved by Xiaoming Peng on behalf of CMMW SG, Second: Stuart Kerry
18.3.3. For: 95, Against: 0, Abstain: 6 (Motion passes 100%)
18.4. CMMW Move to approve response to comments (slide #12)
18.4.1. Move to approve 12/0937r3 as the response to comments on the CMMW PAR and 5
Criteria
18.4.2. Moved by Xiaoming Peng on behalf of CMMW SG, Second: Stuart Kerry
18.4.3. For: 85, Against: 0, Abstain: 8 (Motion passes 100%)

19.

Room Change Requests

19.1. C: TGad has finished with its business for the week, so the other rooms can be released.
19.2. Chair: Is there any objection to adjourning TGad for the week and releasing the rooms?
19.3. No objection.
19.4. C: TGaf does not need the PM1 session today.
19.5. Chair: Is there any objection to releasing the TGaf room for PM1?
19.6. No objection.
19.7. Chair: Any additional rooms required?
19.8. None

20.

Working Group Motions (New Business) (11-12-0735r2)

20.1. STD 802.11-2012 (slide #6)
20.1.1. Move to approve the call for comment as documented in 11-12-0930-00-000Call_for_Comment_2012.ppt.
20.1.2. Moved: Dorothy Stanley, Seconded: Mark Hamilton
20.1.3. Chair: This is planning for success and is hoping that the IEEE 802 EC will allow the

creation of a TGmc group. This motion will then allow formal work to start on updates to
IEEE 802.11-2012 in the September 2012 meeting.
20.1.4. Q: Is it possible to obtain a version of IEEE 802.11-2012 with line numbers?
20.1.5. A: No, not easily. An estimate of the line number will suffice for any comments.
20.1.6. No objection to approving by unanimous consent.
20.2. M.1801 (slide #8)
20.2.1. Approve 18-12/0063r2 containing updates for ITU-R M.1801 related to 802.11.
20.2.2. Moved: Peter Ecclesine, Seconded: Richard Kennedy
20.2.3. Chair: This motion will allow the ITU-R to be kept up to date on the description of IEEE
802.11 and is good work. I would speak in favor of this motion.
20.2.4. Q: What happens if IEEE 802.18 changes something
20.2.5. Chair: Then we will re-consider on Friday.
20.2.6. Q: For TGad, I just want to check that the word “scheduled” is ok for the access scheme.
20.2.7. A: yes, it’s ok.
20.2.8. C: But there needs to be an update of the acronyms table for TGad.
20.2.9. A: Ok.
20.2.10. Chair: IEEE 802.18 needs to approve this document today. Therefore this motion is still
valid.
20.2.11. For: 91, Against: 0, Abstain: 2 (Motion passes 100%)
Minutes

page 8

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

21.


doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

ISD SG name change

21.1. The ISD SG decided to change the name of the study group to avoid confusion with similarly
named groups in the WFA. It is envisaged that this name change will start from September
2012. The new name is “Pre-Association Discovery” (PAD).
21.2. As there was no earlier WFA liaison report, it is useful to mention the WFA liaison document
(11-12-0920r0) that is appropriate to the ISD SG.
21.3. No questions

22.

Central Desktop (presentation to be posted by Jon/Bruce)

22.1. IEEE-SA staff (Christina Boyce): This is a new tool for standards developer’s use.
22.2. There are some meetings here this week to discuss this tool in more detail if you are interested.
22.3. VC2: I was part of the evaluation team and I’d like to note that it does not replace any of our
current tools. However, it may be useful for editorial checks and reviews of drafts prior to
publication etc.
22.4. No questions.

23.

IEEE 802.11 awards (11-12-0722r1)

23.1. Chair: There are three sets of awards today for various projects which have completed this
year.
23.2. Chair: I authorize photographs to be taken of the ceremony.
23.3. No objection

23.4. The three awards are for TGaa, TGae and TGmb (IEEE 802.11-2012)

24.

Any Other Business

24.1. None
24.2. Meeting recessed at 12:36 PDT

Minutes

page 9

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

Friday, 20th July 2012
IEEE 802.11 Closing Plenary
Call to order at 08:01 PDT by Bruce Kraemer (Marvell).
89 people present in the room.

25.

Agenda (11-12-0720r6)

25.1. Chair: At the moment, the meeting is planned to finish at 12:00 PDT, including 15 motions.

There will be a break around 10:00 PDT.
25.2. Any objection to adopting the changes to the agenda.
25.3. None seen

26.

Call for Essential Patents

26.1. Call for Essential Patents and Letters of Assurance (LoA)
26.2. None

27.

Announcements (11-12-0722r1)

27.1. Minutes and documents
27.1.1. Please can everyone remember that minutes, reports, web-updates and timelines should
be completed once the meeting is closed.
27.2. September 2012
27.2.1. There is currently a draft agenda for the September 2012 meeting and there will be our
usual CAC meetings between now and that meeting. Please note that the IEEE 802.11 chair
will not be able to attend, so the meeting will be run by the two vice-chairs.
27.3. LoA (slide #41)
27.3.1. Please look at this slide for a reference to the current LoA database. There are currently 8
entries with 2012 submission dates.
27.4. IEEE Shop (slide #42)
27.4.1. As of 1st July 2012, many IEEE 802 standards are now available for $5. The TGac and
TGad drafts have now been updated. This sale price should continue until the end of the
calendar year.
27.4.2. No questions

27.5. November 2012 tutorials (slide #44)
27.5.1. Chair: If you have any topics for the November 2012 plenary, please can you inform the
chair. At the moment there may be an IEEE 802.1 tutorial.

Minutes

page 10

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

28.

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

Meeting Location

28.1. Chair: Can I have a show of hands to see who is in favor of returning to this location again?
28.2. For: 89, Against: 0
28.3. VC1: Note, we will be here in 2 and 4 years time.

29.

Documentation & Attendance (11-11-0734r0)

29.1. VC2: The documentation system has been working fine this week.
29.2. The IEEE 802.11 attendance was good, with 308 people of 805 at the IEEE 802 plenary.
29.3. TGai and TGaf were the busiest groups this week, with a rapid increase for WNG.

29.4. VC2: Please don’t double click on the attendance server, as it will undo your credit.
29.5. VC2: Voting status updates will be notified over the weekend.
29.6. No questions

30.

WG Reports

30.1. Publicity
30.1.1. Press release as mentioned in 11-12-0880r0
30.2. Timelines
30.2.1. A few changes this time to the TGaf dates that were updated last night.
30.2.2. Secretary: I’d also like to thank Alex Ashley for all his help with this page and reducing it
down in size from 1 Mb to 80kB.
30.2.3. Chair: Also thanks to Clint Chaplin for his historical update analysis [check this on the
timeline page]
30.2.4. No questions

31.

PAR reviews (11-12-0904r1)

31.1. VC1: There were some meetings this week to discuss PARs from other working groups. All of
our comments were accepted and there is nothing controversial.
31.2. No questions

32.

IEEE 802.11 Network Observations


32.1. Rick Alfin (Verilan): I just wanted to give you some feedback about the IEEE 802.11 network
here. This venue is quite nice with a 200 Mb link from the hotel. We have 54 tri-mo APs serving
800 people.
32.2. In addition to this meeting, we now serve larger meetings up to 1800 people in other venues
(e.g. iCAN in Prague). This was served using 11n APs.
32.3. So, IEEE 802.11 works and it works well.
32.4. Chair: Note, that we’re not actually running 11n APs here in our meetings.
32.5. No questions

33.

IEEE 802.16 Study Group (11-12-0973r0)

Minutes

page 11

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

33.1. IEEE 802.16 Chair: This is a follow up from the presentation given in the May 2012 meeting.
33.2. This is a presentation about the HetNet and Metrology study groups. There will be two PARs
presented at the EC this afternoon for new groups today.
33.3. Chair: I understand that the HetNet project may have an impact on IEEE 802.11. Therefore
I’ve tried to indicate when these meetings occur. Would it be possible to have cross credits
between 802.16 and 802.11 to encourage cross participation. Perhaps we need to start doing this

in September.
33.4. IEEE 802.16 Chair: Sure, perhaps we can try and co-ordinate slots in September. I’m sure we
can do something with IMAT.
33.5. VC1: IEEE 802.16 will be in Indian Wells in September 2012
33.6. No questions

34.

WG Committee Reports (11-12-0734r0)

34.1. Technical editor (slide #7)
34.1.1. C: If you recall TGmb have out their awards for IEEE 802.11-2012 on Wednesday. But
we forgot to mention Jon Rosdahl who contributed to TGmb quite extensively. I would like
to mention and congratulate him for his efforts.
34.2. WNG SC (slide #15)
34.2.1. There were 9 presentations this week with an extensive amount of work and discussions.
34.2.2. Chair: One topic within WNG SC was “Cellular Oriented Wi-Fi” (item 3 on slide #15)
which generated a lot of off-line interest. Therefore I propose that during the September
2012 meeting, the Tuesday evening WNG SC be targeted at this topic. Something like
carried orientated WLAN may be a suitable title. I will ask the presenter of this topic to
return in September and possibly re-present on this topic. However, I think that a call for
presentations on this topic is also appropriate. In addition, I think it’s a little early to start a
specific study group on this topic.
34.2.3. VC1: Focusing the WNG SC on this one topic will be the only meeting on the Tuesday
evening with a room size of 250.
34.2.4. Chair: There should also be a tutorial presentation from the IEEE 802.11 community, in
order to educate to the carriers, e.g. unlicensed as opposed to licensed spectrum use.
34.2.5. WNG SC Chair: Another option is to adopt specific Interest Groups (IG)
34.2.6. C: This “cellular” topic is not going to go away. Carriers are terrified about this, and 95%
of Internet traffic is now running over wired and wireless (IEEE 802.11) links. Of course,

they have a difference in perception regarding performance. More and more devices will
have dual mode cellular and WLAN radios. Therefore we need to organize ourselves to work
this through with the carrier people. There must be 6 or 7 other SDOs and for a working on
this topic.
34.2.7. Chair: I encourage you to prepare some material for September please.
34.2.8. A: Sure, I will.
34.2.9. C: This is not a new topic and please remember that this is a volunteer project, so we
need contributions.
34.3. ARC (slide #18)
34.3.1. Q: What is TRILL
34.3.2. A: I can’t remember, but it will come up again later in this meeting.
Minutes

page 12

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

34.4. JTC1 SC (slide #23)
34.4.1. Please remember that this is an IEEE 802 level group.
34.4.2. Q: We have had conflicts between ISO SC6 meetings and IEEE 802.11. Can this be
resolved?
34.4.3. A: We have requested this, and just hope it’s taken into account.
34.5. Regulatory SC (slide #28)
34.5.1. No questions
34.6. TGac (slide #35)

34.6.1. No questions
34.7. TGad (slide #39)
34.7.1. No questions
34.8. TGaf (slide #46)
34.8.1. Please note that document 11-12-0877r0 should be 11-12-0866r0 in the slides.
34.8.2. No questions
34.9. TGah (slide #53)
34.9.1. Chair: Are either your old or new secretaries here, to thank them for their help?
34.9.2. C: No, but we can thank them anyway.
34.9.3. No questions
34.10. TGai (slide #58)
34.10.1. No questions
34.11. CMMW Study Group (slide #71)
34.11.1. Assuming the PAR is approved at the EC today, the task group will be entitled “IEEE
802.11aj”
34.11.2. Chair: Comments may occur at the EC meeting today, not NesCom as stated in the
slides.
34.11.3. Chair: Some people were anticipating attending the first meeting in Beijing. There will
be a letter of invitation from the IEEE office in Beijing for visa applications. So, I’d like to
know how many people in the room, intend to go to this meeting, who are not Chinese
Citizens.
34.11.4. 2 people.
34.11.5. Q: So how will attendance be recorded?
34.11.6. Chair: There will be effectively two interims in September, one in Beijing and one in
Indian Wells. There is a document that discusses all the logistics.
34.11.7. Q: Will this group of people also meeting in Indian Wells?
34.11.8. Chair: They can do if they wish, but there’s no association between them. There will be
no CMMW SG meetings at the Indian Wells meeting in September.
34.12. ISD Study Group (slide #80)
34.12.1. Please note that the ISD SG minutes are actually document 11-12-0960r0 as opposed to

11-12-0670r0. This group will now be known as PAD (Pre-Association Discovery) moving
forward.
Minutes

page 13

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

35.

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

Liaison Reports

35.1. IEEE 802.15 (11-12-0975r1)
35.1.1. Q: what is the difference between r0 and r1
35.1.2. A: Nothing really, except the version number.
35.2. IEEE 802.21 (11-12-0974r0)
35.2.1. No questions
35.3. IEEE 802.18 (11-12-0955r1)
35.3.1. C: I’d like to thank IEEE 802.11 members who helped with M.1801. Also M.1450 will
need a lot of work from IEEE 802.11ac members later on. If it could be done before
September 2012, that would be great. Again, some of the other ITU-R documents need to be
updated and please note that this is advertising for IEEE 802.11
35.3.2. C: I’ve already volunteered to do the TGac updates within M.1450.
35.3.3. Q: Isn’t M.1801 updated with both TGac and TGad material
35.3.4. A: Yes, it was updated with both.


36.

Coffee Break

36.1. Chair: I would like to take a short break and re-convene at 10:00 PDT.
36.2. Is there any objection?
36.3. None seen.

37.

Working Group Motions (Old Business) (11-12-0735r4)

37.1. Teleconferences (slide #14)
37.1.1. Move to approve the following teleconferences

Group
TGai

Dates
Tuesdays from July 31 to Sep 25

Start Time Duration
18:00 ET
1 Hour

TGah

Wed Sept 12 at 10 AM ET 1 hour


10:00 ET

1 Hour

TGac

July 26, August 9, August 23,
Sept 6, Sept 27, Oct 11
August 2, August 16, August 30, Sept 13, Oct. 4
Aug 16, Aug 30, Sept 13, Oct 4
Aug 23, Sept 6, Sept 27, Oct 11

10:00 ET

2 Hours

20:00 ET
10:00 ET
20:00 ET

2 Hours
2 Hours

Tuesdays to November 20th

21:00 ET

2 Hours

TGad

TGaf
Minutes

page 14

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

JTC1, ARC, REG
SCs

Calls to be arranged on 10-days notice as required

CMMW SG

Aug 23, 30

19:00 ET

1 Hour

37.1.2. Moved Adrian Stephens, 2nd Jon Rosdahl
37.1.3. No objection to approving by unanimous consent.
37.2. Working Group Operations Manual (slide #16)
37.2.1. Approve 11-09/0002r12 as the 802.11 Operations Manual
37.2.2. Moved: Jon Rosdahl, Seconded: Adrian Stephens

37.2.3. For: 66, Against: 0, Abstain: 0 (Motion passes 100%)
37.3. Publicity (slide #18)
37.3.1. Approve the press release in document 11-12/919r0 related to the publication of
802.11ae and 802.11aa.
37.3.2. Moved: Stephen McCann, Second: Michael Montemurro
37.3.3. No objection to approving by unanimous consent.
37.4. ANA Request (slide #20)
37.4.1. Motivation: Enable use of WNM-Notification Request frame by WFA
37.4.2. Move to request the ANA to place IEEE Std 802.11™-2012 Table 8-256 “WNMNotification type” under ANA control [reference section 8.5.14.28 “WNM-Notification
Request frame format”] and Request allocation of a value, annotated as “(Reserved for
use by WFA)”. Note: indication in the standard will be “Reserved”.
37.4.3. Moved: Dorothy Stanley, Second: Michael Montemurro
37.4.4. No objection to approving by unanimous consent.
37.5. TGac PAR Extension (slide #22)
37.5.1. Believing that the PAR contained in the document referenced below meets IEEE-SA
guidelines, Request that the PAR contained in 11-12/0940r0 be posted to the IEEE 802
Executive Committee (EC) agenda for EC approval to submit to NesCom.
37.5.2. Moved: Osama Aboul-Magd, Second: Stephen McCann
37.5.3. [TGac vote (on earlier version of this information): Moved: Eldad Perahia, Seconded:
Youhan Kim, Result: 19-0-0]
37.5.4. For: 76, Against: 0, Abstain: 0 (Motion passes 100%)
37.6. TGac Ad Hoc Meeting (slide #23)
37.6.1. Authorize TGac to hold an ad-hoc meeting on November 8-9 in the Bay Area, for the
purpose of working on comment resolution.
37.6.2. Moved by Osama Aboul-Magd on behalf of TGac
37.6.3. [TGac vote: Moved: Eldad Perahia, Seconded: Brian Hart, Result: 19-2-3]
37.6.4. No objection to approving by unanimous consent.
37.7. TGaf Letter Ballot (slide #25)
37.7.1. Having approved TGaf Draft 2.0,
Minutes


page 15

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

37.7.2. Approve a 30 day Working Group Technical Letter Ballot asking the question
“Should TGaf D2.0 be forwarded to Sponsor Ballot?”
37.7.3. Moved by Rich Kennedy on behalf of TGaf
37.7.4. [TGaf vote: 22/0/0]
37.7.5. For: 77, Against: 0, Abstain: 0 (Motion passes 100%)
37.7.6. TGaf Chair: Please can members also read 11-12-0866r1 for some information, prior to
reviewing the draft.
37.7.7. VC2: I’ll try and start the ePoll at midnight tonight.
37.8. CMMW Logistics Document (slide #27)
37.8.1. Move to approve CMMW Task Group logistics contained in document 12/0827r2
37.8.2. Moved by Xiaoming Peng on behalf of CMMW SG, Second: Eldad Perahia
37.8.3. [CMMW SG vote: Moved: Haiming Wang, Seconded: Edward Au, Result:10-0-1]
37.8.4. For: 77, Against: 0, Abstain: 1 (Motion passes 100%)
37.9. CMMW Meeting Logistics and Agenda (slide #28)
37.9.1. Move to approve meeting logistics and agenda (in 12/0887r0, slides 4 & 5) for
September CMMW Interim in Beijing
37.9.2. Moved by Xiaoming Peng, Seconded: Eldad Perahia
37.9.3. For: 69, Against: 0, Abstain: 2 (Motion passes 100%)
37.10. CMMW Study Group Extension (slide #29)
37.10.1. Request the IEEE 802 LMSC to extend the 802.11 CMMW Study Group.

37.10.2. Moved by Xiaoming Peng on behalf of CMMW SG, Seconded: Eldad Perahia
37.10.3. [CMMW SG vote: Moved: Haiming Wang, Seconded: Edward Au, Result: 14-0-0]
37.10.4. For: 75, Against: 0, Abstain: 0 (Motion passes 100%)
37.11. CMMW Rationale for Study Group Extension (slide #30)
37.11.1. Move to approve “Rationale for Study Group Extension” on slide 25 of 12/886r3
37.11.2. Moved by Xiaoming Peng on behalf of CMMW SG, Seconded: Eldad Perahia
37.11.3. [CMMW SG vote: Moved: Edward Au, Seconded: Haiming Wang, Result: 14-0-0]
37.11.4. For: 72, Against: 0, Abstain: 0 (Motion passes 100%)
37.12. PAD Study Group Extension (slide #32)
37.12.1. Request the IEEE 802 LMSC to extend the IEEE 802.11 PAD Study Group.
37.12.2. Note: this is to allow further work to finalise PAR and 5 Criteria documentation.
37.12.3. Moved by Stephen McCann on behalf of ISD (PAD) SG, Seconded: Dwight Smith
37.12.4. [PAD SG vote: Moved: Harry Worstell, Second: Dwight Smith, Result: 29/0/0]
37.12.5. For: 71, Against: 0, Abstain: 0 (Motion passes 100%)

38.

Working Group Motions (New Business) (11-12-0735r4)

38.1. Link Study Group Creation (slide #34)
38.1.1. Motion: Request approval by IEEE 802 LMSC to form a Study Group on enabling
the use of 802.11 (including consideration of infrastructure BSS, PBSS, and IBSS
associations) as general transit links capable of supporting 802.1 bridging, with the
intent of creating a PAR and five criteria.
38.1.2. Straw poll on similar motion in WNG: 67 yes, 0 no, 45 abstain
Minutes

page 16

Stephen McCann, RIM



July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

38.1.3. Straw poll on similar motion in ARC: 8 yes, 0 no, 0 abstain
38.1.4. Moved: Peter Ecclesine, Seconded: Mark Hamilton
38.1.5. C: This will be called “GLK SG”.
38.1.6. Chair: There was an identical motion passed by IEEE 802.1 yesterday, so there will be
two study groups working in parallel. At the Vancouver meeting next January 2013, there
will be joint meetings.
38.1.7. Q: Is motion is for an IEEE 802.11 Study Group?
38.1.8. Chair: By implication since we have a motion in this body, it will be for an IEEE 802.11
study group.
38.1.9. C: The IEEE 802.11 will focus on a PAR and 5C for changes to IEEE 802.11 and then the
IEEE 802.1 study group will do the same thing for IEEE 802.1.
38.1.10. For: 56, Against: 0, Abstain: 5 (Motion passes 100%)
38.2. TRILL Liaison (slide #36)
38.2.1. Motion: Request the IEEE 802.11 WG chair transmit the liaison on slide 21 of “1112-0621-04-0000-alternative-path-selection-protocol.pptx” to the IETF TRILL WG and
any additional persons he deems appropriate.
38.2.2. Moved: Dorothy Stanley, Seconded: Andrew Myles
38.2.3. C: The text now says the IEEE 802.11 has no view on whether IETF TRILL does this or
not, so I’m now happy to support this motion.
38.2.4. Q: Can I just check that slide #21 is the correct reference.
38.2.5. A: Yes, it is.
38.2.6. For: 62, Against: 0, Abstain: 3 (Motion passes 100%)
38.3. IETF IANA Diffie-Hellman Group Liaison (slide #44)
38.3.1. Motion: Request the IEEE 802.11 WG chair transmit the liaison on slide 5 of “1112-0970-00-0000-ietf-liaison-on-diffie-hellman-groups.potx” to the IETF Security Area
Directors and any persons he deems appropriate.

38.3.2. Moved: Dan Harkins, Seconded: Michael Montemurro
38.3.3. Q: Regarding slide #42, do we currently have any references in IEEE 802.11-2012 to
“brainpool curves.”
38.3.4. A: Not at the moment.
38.3.5. C: Ok, so this text should say that we may do in the future.
38.3.6. A: There is not future work required in modifying IEEE 802.11-2012.
38.3.7. Q: So, is there incorporation by reference?
38.3.8. A: Yes
38.3.9. For: 52, Against: 0, Abstain: 4 (Motion passes 100%)

39.

Interpretation Request (11-12-0459r0)

39.1. This is regarding 802.11n.
39.2. Move to approve the response in 11-12-0459-00 as the IEEE 802.11 WG interpretation
response to the indicated interpretation request.
39.2.1. Moved: Dorothy Stanley, 2nd : Eldad Perahia
39.2.2. For: 59, Against: 0, Abstain: 2 (Motion passes 100%)

40.

Future Venues (11-12-0722r2)

Minutes

page 17

Stephen McCann, RIM



July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

40.1. Chair: Our next meeting (session #135) is in Indian Wells, California. USA. Please note that
hotel and meeting registration are now both open. The registration early bird finishes on Friday
August 3rd. The hotel early bird finishes on the 23rd July.
40.2. Chair: Regarding September 2014, it looks as though we’ll go to Kobe, Japan, but there are
still some details to work out.
40.3. Q: Regarding 2013, we only have 1 plenary outside of the USA/North America.
40.4. Chair: Yes, we’re slowly trying to change this culture.
40.5. VC1: Please see document IEEE 802 EC-12/0039r1 slide 19 for more information on this. The
EC is gradually moving in the direction of having more Non-US/Non-NA venues. So, you can
see that we’re trying to change some meetings around to meet this requirement. We still have
contracts for Waikoloa, Hawaii, USA in July 2015 and July 2017, which could be changed. The
EC has now been advised that there should be no more Waikoloa meetings after this.

41.

Other New Business

41.1. None

42.

Adjournment

42.1. Chair: I propose to adjourn
42.2. The meeting is adjourned without objection at 11:01 PDT


Minutes

page 18

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

Annex A: Attendance & Affiliation
Name

Attended
>= 75%?

Affiliation

Aboulmagd, Osama

Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd

Yes

Abraham, Santosh

Qualcomm Incorporated


Yes

Aiello, Roberto

Itron Inc.

Yes

Aikens, Valentine

Western Digital Corporation

Yes

Alexander, Thomas

Ixia

Yes

Amini, Peiman

Broadcom Corporation

Yes

Ariyavisitakul, Sirikiat Lek

Broadcom Corporation


Yes

Armstrong, Lee

US Department of Transportation

Yes

Asai, Yusuke

NTT

Yes

Ashley, Alex

NDS Limited

Yes

Asterjadhi, Alfred

Qualcomm Incorporated

Yes

Astrin, Arthur

Astrin Radio


No

Au, Kwok Shum

Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd

Yes

Auluck, Vijay

Intel Corporation

Yes

Aust, Stefan

NEC Communication Systems, Ltd.

Yes

Awater, Geert

Qualcomm Incorporated

Yes

Baik, Eugene

Qualcomm Incorporated


Yes

Bajko, Gabor

Nokia

Yes

Banerjea, Raja

CSR

Yes

Barber, Phillip

Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd

Yes

Batra, Anuj

Texas Instruments Incorporated

Yes

Ben-Tovim, Erez

Sigma Designs


Yes

Bhandaru, Nehru

Broadcom Corporation

Yes

Bourdoux, Andre

IMEC

Yes

Bozorgebrahimi, Kurosh

Uninet

No

Buffington, John

Itron Inc.

Yes

Cai, Lin

Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd


Yes

Cain, Brent

Itron Inc.

Yes

Calcev, George

Huawei R&D USA

Yes

Canchi, Radhakrishna

Kyocera Communications Inc.

No

Cariou, Laurent

France Telecom

Yes

Carney, William

Sony Corporation


Yes

Cha, Jaesun

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

No

Minutes

page 19

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

Name

Attended
>= 75%?

Affiliation

Chang, Kim

Huawei R&D USA


Yes

Chang, Kuor-Hsin

Elster Solutions

No

Chang, Sung-Cheol

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

No

Chang, Xin

Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd

No

Chaplin, Clint

Samsung Information Systems America, Inc.

No

Chen, Jiamin

Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd


Yes

Chen, Lidong

NIST

Yes

Cheong, Minho

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

Yes

CHERIAN, GEORGE

Qualcomm Incorporated

Yes

Chitrakar, Rojan

Panasonic Singapore

Yes

Cho, Seungkwon

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)


No

Choi, Jinsoo

LG ELECTRONICS

No

Choo, Li Chia

Institute for Infocomm Research

Yes

Choudhury, Sayantan

Nokia

Yes

Chu, Liwen

STMicroelectronics

Yes

Chu, Wenjing

Dell


Yes

CHUN, JINYOUNG

LG ELECTRONICS

No

Coffey, John

Realtek Semiconductor Corp.

Yes

Cook, Charles

CenturyLink, Inc.

No

Cordeiro, Carlos

Intel Corporation

Yes

Correal, Neiyer

Motorola Solutions, Inc.


Yes

de la Garrigue, Michael

Xirrus Corporation

No

De Ruijter, Hendricus

Silicon Laboratories

No

de Vegt, Rolf

Qualcomm Incorporated

Yes

denson, michael

Cambridge Silicon Radio

Yes

Derham, Thomas

France Telecom


Yes

dhaliwal, Upkarjit

Future Wireless Technologies

Yes

Doppler, Klaus

Nokia

Yes

Durand, Roger

Research In Motion Limited

Yes

Eastlake 3rd, Donald

Huawei R&D USA

Yes

Ecclesine, Peter

Cisco Systems, Inc.


Yes

Edgar, Richard

CSR plc.

Yes

Ekbal, Amal

National Instruments Corporation

Yes

El Ezabi, Ayman

American University in Cairo

Yes

Emmelmann, Marc

Fraunhofer FOKUS

Yes

Minutes

page 20


Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

Name

Attended
>= 75%?

Affiliation

Erceg, Vinko

Broadcom Corporation

Yes

Fang, Ping

Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd

Yes

Fang, Yonggang

ZTE Corporation


Yes

Farhadi, Golnaz

Fujitsu Laboratories of America, Inc.

No

Fischer, Mathew

Broadcom Corporation

Yes

Flammer, George

Silver Spring Networks Inc.

Yes

FLYNN, P

Texas Instruments Incorporated

No

Fukui, Kiyoshi

Oki Electric Industry Co., Ltd.


No

Ghosh, Chitabrata

Nokia

Yes

Goodall, David

Broadcom Corporation

Yes

Grandhi, Sudheer

InterDigital, Inc.

Yes

Grau, Stephen

Juniper Networks, Inc.

Yes

Hagen, Mikkel

University of New Hampshire InterOperability Laboratory (UNH-IOL)


No

Halasz, David

Motorola Mobility

Yes

Hamilton, Mark

Polycom, Inc.

Yes

Hansen, Christopher

Apple, Inc.

Yes

Harada, Hiroshi

National Institute of Information and Communications Technology (NICT)

No

Hares, Susan

Huawei R&D USA


Yes

Harkins, Dan

Aruba Networks, Inc.

Yes

Hart, Brian

Cisco Systems, Inc.

Yes

Hedayat, Ahmadreza

Cisco Systems, Inc.

Yes

Heide, Carolyn

Ruckus Wireless

Yes

Henry, Jerome

IEEE Member / Self


Yes

Hillman, Garth

OakTree Wireless

Yes

Hoang, Anh Tuan

Institute for Infocomm Research

No

Hoang, Dien

National Institute of Information and Communications Technology (NICT)

No

HOSAKO, IWAO

National Institute of Information and Communications Technology (NICT)

No

hsiao, ying-chuan

Industrial Technology Research Institute (ITRI)


Yes

Hu, Chunyu

Broadcom Corporation

Yes

HU, Nan

China Mobile Communications Corporation (CMCC)

No

Huang, Rongsheng

Olympus Communication Technology of America, Inc.

No

Hunter, David

WireFi Networks Inc.

Yes

Hwang, Sung Hyun

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)


Yes

Inoue, Yasuhiko

Nippon Telegraph and Telephone Corporation (NTT)

Yes

Iwaoka, Mitsuru

Yokogawa Electric Corporation

No

Minutes

page 21

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

Name

Attended
>= 75%?


Affiliation

Jeong, Wuncheol

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

Yes

Jeong, Yangseok

KT Corp.

Yes

Jindal, Nihar

Broadcom Corporation

Yes

Jones, Girault

No

Jones, Vince

Qualcomm Incorporated

Yes


JOO, SEONG-SOON

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

Yes

Junell, Jari

Nokia

Yes

Kafle, Padam

Nokia

Yes

Kain, Carl

Noblis, Inc.

Yes

Kammaje, Ravi

Nexilica Inc

Yes


Kang, Chung

Korea University

No

Kang, Hyunduk

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

Yes

Kang, Hyunjeong

Samsung Electronics

Yes

Kasslin, Mika

Nokia

Yes

Kawamura, Masahiko

Kozo Keikaku Engineering Inc.

No


Kennedy, Richard

Research In Motion Limited

Yes

Kerry, Stuart

OK-Brit

Yes

Kim, Eunkyung

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

No

Kim, Jeongki

LG ELECTRONICS

No

Kim, Jinho

LG ELECTRONICS

Yes


Kim, Jinkyeong

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

No

Kim, Joo Young

KT Corp.

Yes

Kim, Joonsuk

Broadcom Corporation

Yes

Kim, Kihong

ICS

No

kim, Seong Soo

Samsung

No


Kim, Sinhyo

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

Yes

Kim, Suhwook

LG ELECTRONICS

Yes

Kim, Taejoon

Nokia Research Center

Yes

Kim, Youhan

Qualcomm Incorporated

Yes

Kim, Youngsoo

Samsung Electronics

Yes


KIM, YUN HEE

Kyung Hee University

Yes

Kitazawa, Shoichi

ATR Wave Engineering Laboratories

No

Kivinen, Tero

AuthenTec

No

KNECKT, JARKKO

Nokia

Yes

Ko, Gwangzeen

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

No


Minutes

page 22

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

Name

Attended
>= 75%?

Affiliation

Kojima, Fumihide

National Institute of Information and Communications Technology (NICT)

No

Kolze, Tom

Broadcom Corporation

Yes


Koskela, Timo

Renesas Mobile Corporation

Yes

Kraemer, Bruce

Marvell Semiconductor, Inc.

Yes

Kurihara, Thomas

TKstds Management

Yes

Kwak, Byung-Jae

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

No

Kwak, Jin-Sam

LG ELECTRONICS

No


Kwak, Joseph

InterDigital, Inc.

Yes

Kwon, Hyoungjin

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

Yes

Kwon, Soon Yil

LG ELECTRONICS

No

Kwon, Young Hoon

Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd

Yes

Lackner, Hans

QoSCom

No


LAGRANGE, Pascal

Canon Research Centre France

No

Lambert, Paul

Marvell Semiconductor, Inc.

No

Lan, Zhou

National Institute of Information and Communications Technology (NICT)

No

Lansford, James

CSR plc.

Yes

Le Rouzic, Jean-Pierre

France Telecom

Yes


Lee, Anseok

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

No

Lee, Donghun

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

Yes

Lee, Hyeong Ho

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

No

Lee, Jae Seung

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

No

Lee, Sokjoon

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

Yes


Lee, Wookbong

LG ELECTRONICS

No

Lei, Zhongding

Institute for Infocomm Research

Yes

Lertsirisopon, Navarat

Kozo Keikaku Engineering Inc.

Yes

Levy, Joseph

InterDigital Communications, LLC

Yes

Li, Feng

China Academy of Telecommunication Technology(CATT)

No


Li, Hsia-Hsin

Industrial Technology Research Institute (ITRI)

Yes

Li, Huan-Bang

National Institute of Information and Communications Technology (NICT)

Yes

Li, Liang

Vinno Technologies Inc.

Yes

LI, YUNZHOU

Tsinghua University

Yes

Liu, Yong

Marvell Semiconductor, Inc.

Yes


Loc, Peter

Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd

Yes

luo, hui

China Academy of Telecommunication Research (CATR)

Yes

Luo, Zhendong

China Academy of Telecommunication Research (CATR)

Yes

Minutes

page 23

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

Name


Attended
>= 75%?

Affiliation

Lv, Kaiying

ZTE Corporation

Yes

Lynch, Michael

MJ Lynch & Associates, LLC.

No

Malinen, Jouni

Qualcomm Incorporated

Yes

Mano, Hiroshi

Alliedtelesis R&D center K.K.

Yes


Mccann, Stephen

Research In Motion Limited

Yes

Merlin, Simone

Qualcomm Incorporated

Yes

Miller, James

InterDigital, Inc.

Yes

Mizutani, Keiichi

National Institute of Information and Communications Technology (NICT)

Yes

Mlinarsky, Fanny

octoScope

Yes


Montemurro, Michael

Research In Motion Limited

Yes

Mori, Kenichi

Panasonic Corporation

No

Mori, Taeko

ISB Corporation

No

Morioka, Hitoshi

Allied Telesis R&D Ceter

Yes

Mukherjee, Sayandev

NTT DoCoMo, Inc.

Yes


Murias, Ronald

InterDigital, Inc.

Yes

Myles, Andrew

Cisco Systems, Inc.

Yes

Nafie, Mohammed

Nile University

Yes

Nagai, Yukimasa

Mitsubishi Electric Corporation

Yes

Nagao, Yuhei

Radrix Co., Ltd

Yes


Nakano, Hiroki

Trans New Technology, Inc.

Yes

Nandagopalan, SAI
SHANKAR

Tensorcom, Inc.

Yes

Ngo, Chiu

Samsung

No

Ogawa, Hiroyo

Association of Radio Industries and Businesses (ARIB)

Yes

Oh, Minseok

Kyonggi University

Yes


OH, MIN-SEOK

LG ELECTRONICS

No

Onishi, Hirofumi

Alpine Electronics

No

Onishi, Ryokichi

Toyota InfoTechnology Center

Yes

Oyama, Satoshi

Association of Radio Industries and Businesses (ARIB)

Yes

Pandey, Santosh
Ghanshyam

Cisco Systems, Inc.


Yes

Pantelidou, Anna

Renesas Mobile Corporation

Yes

Park, Giwon

LG ELECTRONICS

No

Park, Hyunho

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

No

Park, Minyoung

Intel Corporation

Yes

Park, Seung-Hoon

Samsung Electronics


Yes

Minutes

page 24

Stephen McCann, RIM


July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0873r0

Name

Attended
>= 75%?

Affiliation

Parsons, Glenn

Ericsson AB

No

Patil, Sandhya

Samsung


No

Peng, Xiaoming

Institute for Infocomm Research

Yes

Perahia, Eldad

Intel Corporation

Yes

Perez Costa, Xavier

NEC Laboratories Europe

Yes

Perkins, Charles

No

Petranovich, James

ViaSat, Inc.

Yes


petrick, Albert

Jones-Petrick and Associates, LLC.

Yes

Petro, John

NSA/IAD

Yes

Pirhonen, Riku

IEEE Member / Self

Yes

Pirskanen, Juho

Renesas Mobile Corporation

Yes

Poegel, Frank

Atmel Corporation

No


Popa, Daniel

Itron Inc.

No

Pope, Steve

Self Employed

Yes

porat, ron

Broadcom Corporation

Yes

Ptasinski, Henry

NO AFFILIATION

Yes

Pulikkoonatu, Rethnakaran Broadcom Corporation

Yes

Qi, Emily


Intel Corporation

Yes

Qu, Huyu

Honeywell International Inc.

Yes

Ramamurthy, Harish

Marvell Semiconductor, Inc.

Yes

Rayment, Stephen

Ericsson AB

Yes

Reede, Ivan

AmeriSys Inc.

Yes

Ressl, Michael


Hitachi Cable America Inc.

No

Reuss, Edward

Clair Global

Yes

Reznik, Alex

InterDigital, Inc.

No

Riegel, Maximilian

Nokia Siemens Networks

Yes

Rong, Zhigang

Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd

Yes

Rosdahl, Jon


CSR plc.

Yes

Ryu, Cheol

Electronics and Telecommunications Research Instititute (ETRI)

Yes

Safonov, Alexander

IITP RAS

Yes

Sakoda, Kazuyuki

Sony Corporation

Yes

Salazar Cardozo, Ruben

Landis Gyr Group Worldwide

Yes

Sampath, Hemanth


Qualcomm Incorporated

No

Sato, Naotaka

Sony

No

Sayana, Krishnakamal

SAMSUNG

No

Minutes

page 25

Stephen McCann, RIM